Skip navigation

Mutual Fund News

The long and short of a market neutral strategy


For many investors, the stock market's dramatic ups and downs have been unnerving.

And market neutral hedge funds - which try to give zero market risk by balancing long and short positions and make money under all conditions - may gain more attention as more people seek alternative investment strategies.

"Those funds are not designed to shoot the lights out," said Dan Hallett, a fund analyst and director of asset management at HighView Financial Group. "They are designed to earn absolute returns, so a T-bill-plus return in any market."

They can provide diversification because they are not correlated to the market and should be able to make money even if the market gets stuck in a trading range, he noted.

"The difficulty is finding good hedge funds," Mr. Hallett said. "The stakes are higher because you are taking both long and short positions."

Here is a taste of some existing funds.

Picton Mahoney

Market Neutral

David Picton aims to score a return of about 8 per cent per annum for his fund invested in Canadian stocks.

Using fundamental and quantitative analysis, he buys companies with strong earnings momentum and positive changes, and uses the opposite criteria for stocks to short.

"We might have up to 200 longs and shorts, but most of the weight is concentrated in about 50 or 60 longs or 50 or 60 shorts," said the manager with Picton Mahoney Asset Management Inc.

Mr. Picton, who also runs mutual funds for CI Investments Inc., said the longs in his hedge fund are generally names in the CI Synergy Canadian Corporate Class fund.

"When you add in those short positions, you can build different correlations and different risk profiles that make your fund completely different from the market," he said.

Sentry Select

Market Neutral

Andrew McCreath aims for equity returns with bond-like volatility in his fund.

His fund's volatility is under 5 per cent [as measure by standard deviation] or less than a quarter of the S&P/TSX composite.

Market neutral funds will be an increasingly attractive alternative to bond funds given fears of rising interest rates," the manager at Sentry Select Capital Corp. said

Mr. McCreath targets annual returns of 8 to 10 per cent per for his fund, which is invested in North American stocks. To reduce risk, he avoids investing in private companies; invests no more than 5 per cent in any single holding and has less than 10 per cent in small-cap stocks.

He typically owns 50 to 55 stocks and uses pairs trades - buying one stock and shorting another, often in the same sector - strategically. "I'm a stock picker," he said. "I am not taking any directional bets."

Fiera Market

Neutral Equity

Jean-Philippe Choquette targets an 8- to 10-per-cent annual return, but garnered more than 25 per cent in 2009.

But he will admit that last year's robust performance in his fund, which is split between Canadian and U.S. stocks, is not sustainable.

The fund benefited from his sector-based pairs strategy that worked well in last year's extremely volatile market. He usually has about 30 to 35 pairs in his fund.

"We are stock pickers," the manager at Fiera Capital said. "We meet with management [of companies] everyday to identify what are key catalysts for shares."

The fund doesn't focus on a style in terms of growth or value stocks, he said. "We just want to make money."

SciVest Market

Neutral Equity

John Schmitz takes diversification to stratospheric levels in his market neutral fund.

"We typically have about 800 to 850 individuals stocks around the world" with more shorts than longs because betting on a declining shares is theoretically more risky, the manager with SciVest Capital Management Inc. said

He uses quantitative analysis to select stocks and model predicted returns, but he isn't looking for home runs.

"It's all about the spread between the long and the short - picking up nickels and even pennies along the way, as opposed to trying for dollars," Mr. Schmitz said.

He suggested that a market neutral strategy is going to be one of the few ways to generate more than a 6-per-cent return given the direction of the U.S. market.

"I think we are in a multiyear trading range," Mr. Schmitz said.

"We are at the tail end of a cyclical bull market in a secular bear that started in 2001."


How market neutral strategies have fared in recent years

Assets* Latest (Feb. 28) Calendar year returns %
Name ($ mil) MER % 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 Incpt
SciVest Market Neutral Equity134.5-
Fiera N.A. Market Neutral II**3.826.810.022.0
Fiera Market Neutral Equity A***562.253.725.78.1
Picton Mahoney Market Neutral Cl A202.491.78.61.314.134.413.9
Sentry Select Market Neutral LP-B171.
Picton Mahoney Gl Mkts Neutral Eq-A23.68-0.60.1-7.8-3.2
Hillsdale Market Neutral Equity A****-14.3-6.115.3-
MSCI World ($ Cdn)-2.211.8-26.1-
S&P 500 Composite ($ Cdn)-0.45.5-23.8-12.213.6-0.2
S&P/TSX Total Return-0.635.1-33.09.817.324.1
*as of February, 2009
**Managed by Jean-Philippe Choquette since inception but targeted to institutional investors
***Managed by Jean-Philippe Choquette since Jan. 1, 2009
****Terminated in December, 2009
Source: Globe Investor, companies

© 2007 The Globe and Mail. All rights reserved.

Search Fund News

Advanced Search

Only GlobeinvestorGOLD combines the strength of powerful investing tools with the insight of The Globe and Mail.

Discover a wealth of investment information and and exclusive features.

Free E-Mail Newsletters

  • Morning news headlines
  • Morning business headlines
  • Financial highlights
  • Tech alert
  • Leisure

Sign-up for our free newsletters

Back to top