Skip navigation

Mutual Fund News

Mutual fund dogs of 2010 suffer more losses in 2011

What are we looking for?

How the mutual fund dogs of 2010 fared last year.

Given the extremely, volatile stock markets in 2011, let's see if these funds extended their losses.

The screen

We focused on the 15 funds with the most red ink in 2010, and then examined their returns last year until Dec. 16. U.S. dollar and duplicate versions of the funds were excluded.

What did we find?

Most suffered more bleeding in 2011.

AGF European Equity Class, the worst performer in 2010 with 20.3-per-cent loss, shed another 22.2 per cent. AGF International Stock, which lost 11.5 per cent in 2010, sank an additional 18.1 per cent.

Both had heavy exposure to European financial stocks that have been beaten up on concerns about the euro-zone debt crisis. The two funds were formerly run by AGF Management's Dublin-based manager John Arnold, who retired last October. His protégé Rory Flynn is now trying to turn the ship around.

On the other hand, Mackenzie Ivy European Fund, which lost 12.1 per cent in 2010, only shed another 2 per cent. This fund, however, has undergone a makeover over the past year. Formerly called Mackenzie Universal European Opportunities, it was run for years by British-based Henderson Global Investors Ltd.

Now it is under the wing of Mackenzie Financial's in-house manager Paul Musson, who heads the Ivy-branded funds. He has made this European fund into a twin of his Mackenzie Ivy European Class, which is a younger, smaller fund with a better five-year record.

Two alternative energy funds lost more money last year as solar stocks were pummelled amid subsidy cuts to the industry and stiffer competition from Chinese manufacturers. PowerShares Global Clean Energy Portfolio and Creststreet Alternative Energy lost another 42 per cent and 37.7 per cent, respectively.

TIS Preservation & Growth, which shed 13.6 per cent in 2010, was the only fund on the list with a positive return. It gained 3.7-per-cent, but that was a fluke. The fund is being wound up, and only holds a stake in a private U.S. company. This U.S.-dollar security hasn't changed in value so the performance depends on the conversion rate to Canadian dollars, said Peter Shippen, president of Redwood Asset Management, which acquired the fund in 2009.


Last Reported 2010Year to DateTo Nov. 30, 2011
Fund NameCategoryMERAssets in $millionsJan.1 to Dec. 31To Dec. 16, 2011To Nov. 30, 20111 Year3 Years5 Years10 Years
AGF European Equity ClassEuropean equity3.11251.9-20.32% -22.22%-17.89% -14.34%-8.29%-14.97%-1.64%
PowerShare Gl Clean Energy Cl AMiscellaneous - sector equity2.041.3-18.57%-42.04%-35.16%-30.57%
TIS Preservation & GrowthGlobal equity4.960.7-13.56%3.67%1.58%-0.49%-7.72%
Investors Summa Global Environ Ldrs AGlobal small/mid cap equity2.7311.1-12.49%-15.36%-13.19%-10.85%0.89%
Mackenzie Ivy European FundEuropean equity2.4892.9-12.09%-2.02%2.33%4.00%0.93%-9.01%-0.33%
AGF International Stock ClassInternational equity3.07354.6-11.50%-18.04%-14.12%-10.53%-2.73%-10.94%-1.36%
Investors Tact Asset Allocation-AGlobal equity balanced2.84475.1-8.47%-9.92%-8.72%-6.32%-1.72%-4.20%
Manulife Global AdvantageFinancial services equity3.0715.1-7.53%-13.83%-7.55%-2.21%4.50%-17.51%-10.10%
Creststreet Alternative EnergyMiscellaneous - undisclosed holdings7.644.2-7.52%-37.65%-32.84%-28.50%-7.96%
Stone & Co. EuroPlus Div Growth AEuropean equity2.948.0-6.62%-2.08%0.72%4.53%3.67%
Caldwell Global Financial ServicesFinancial services equity2.756.0-6.40%-11.14%-7.95%-3.78%1.97%-2.66%
Investors Global Financial Services-AFinancial services equity2.7425.5-6.38%-25.39%-23.72%-18.39%-5.23%-17.26%
BMO Sustainable Climate ClassGlobal small/mid cap equity2.574.8-6.19%-19.65%-15.52%-11.11%2.35%
HSBC Chinese Equity-IGreater China equity2.69195.5-6.19%-18.35%-21.04%-24.13%2.88%-1.99%
TD Global Sustainability-IGlobal equity2.568.8-6.15%-14.39%-11.82%-7.61%-1.34%
S&P/TSX Total Return17.61%-11.26%-7.13%-3.33%12.82%1.95%0.076
S&P 500 Composite Total Return Index($Cdn)9.35%-1.40%3.64%7.14%7.01%-2.40%-0.015
MSCI World ($ Cdn)6.76%-2.60%1.35%5.91%-3.61%-0.002
Source: Globe Investor, Bloomberg, company

© 2007 The Globe and Mail. All rights reserved.

Search Fund News

Advanced Search

Only GlobeinvestorGOLD combines the strength of powerful investing tools with the insight of The Globe and Mail.

Discover a wealth of investment information and and exclusive features.

Free E-Mail Newsletters

  • Morning news headlines
  • Morning business headlines
  • Financial highlights
  • Tech alert
  • Leisure

Sign-up for our free newsletters

Back to top