Skip navigation

Mutual Fund News

Former ETF rivals are now family

The BlackRock-Claymore deal gives investors more choice for exchange-traded funds under one roof

Special to The Globe and Mail

Mary Anne Wiley savours the one coffee she allows herself each day and talks about the current buzz that's coursing through her industry: BlackRock's acquisition of exchange traded funds competitor Claymore Canada.

The combination of Canada's two largest ETF providers will offer investors a comprehensive suite of products, while giving BlackRock added heft to take on its most formidable competition in the asset management sphere - the mutual fund industry, says Ms. Wiley, managing director of iShares for BlackRock Asset Management Canada Ltd.

As of Dec. 31, BlackRock offered 48 ETFs in Canada, representing $29-billion in assets under management, and Claymore offered 34 ETFs and two closed-end funds representing $6.9-billion in assets. Combined, operating under BlackRock's iShares brand, they will account for 85 per cent of the Canadian ETF market.

"We know there's demand for both product lineups ... Our overarching goal is to make sure that at the end of the day, when the deal closes, clients feel they now have an even more powerful product lineup and service provider with the combined entity. What that's actually going to look like is exactly the work that we are doing now," Ms. Wiley says.

It was Claymore that initiated the deal with BlackRock, after weighing the intentions of several suitors, says Som Seif, who started what became Claymore's Canadian operations.

Toronto-based Claymore was a unit of U.S.-based ETF provider Claymore Group Inc. before being acquired by New York-based Guggenheim Partners LLC in 2009. It was put up for sale last fall, with BlackRock announcing its acquisition of Guggenheim's Canadian Claymore subsidiary for an undisclosed price in January. The deal is expected to close at the end of the first quarter of 2012, subject to regulatory approval.

Although it will ultimately be BlackRock's call, "we don't see any real [fund] closures or changes in mandate on either side, as there isn't really much overlap across the funds," says Mr. Seif, president and chief executive officer of Claymore Canada.

ETFs, which trade on stock exchanges, typically track an index or asset class. Unlike actively managed mutual funds, which strive to beat stock market benchmarks, ETFs, for the most part, are passive investment vehicles designed to replicate the returns of the indexes they track. BlackRock focuses on market-capitalization weighted indexes, while Claymore ETFs take a different approach, tracking indexes based on "fundamental" factors, such as dividends and cash flow.

Claymore has different fixed-income product offerings, "they have non-cap-weighted equity and they have a really attractive commodity lineup," Ms. Wiley says.

Adrian Mastracci, portfolio manager at KCM Wealth Management Inc. in Vancouver, says that, while BlackRock and Claymore take different approaches, there are enough similarities that he is "sure there is going to be some amalgamation" of funds once the deal closes.

"We are not happy to see Claymore go, of course, because we like competition. Competition is good for investors, and it's good for advisers when we have more things to look at. So we are probably going to lose some things [as a result of the acquisition], and we are just going to have to deal with that."

Still, Mr. Mastracci adds, it is a vibrant market and new products will emerge - both from the BlackRock-Claymore combination and their competitors in the ETF field, including establishment players such as Bank of Montreal and Royal Bank of Canada, along with Toronto-based Horizons ETF Management Inc. and new entrant Vanguard Group Inc.

Investor awareness "is very high now," says Ms. Wiley, a University of Western Ontario sociology graduate who landed in the asset management field by happenstance when she was hired to fill in for a maternity leave at State Street Global Advisors. Discovering a passion for the business, Ms. Wiley went on to earn her chartered financial analyst designation and "has never looked back."

ETF assets are now equivalent to about 5 per cent of all mutual fund assets under management in Canada, up from 3.6 per cent three years ago.

With its Claymore acquisition, BlackRock is in a better position to capitalize on the growing appetite for ETFs with a broad range of products that, she says, have "democratized investing" by giving individual investors access to institutional-class investment opportunities for relatively low fees compared with the management expense ratios charged by mutual fund managers.

"The markets are not delivering double-digit returns, nor does anybody expect that's going to happen any time soon, I would think." As a result, investors are paying much closer attention to how much they are shelling out in management fees, she says.

© 2007 The Globe and Mail. All rights reserved.

Search Fund News

Advanced Search

Only GlobeinvestorGOLD combines the strength of powerful investing tools with the insight of The Globe and Mail.

Discover a wealth of investment information and and exclusive features.

Free E-Mail Newsletters

  • Morning news headlines
  • Morning business headlines
  • Financial highlights
  • Tech alert
  • Leisure

Sign-up for our free newsletters

Back to top