What are we looking for?
Stars among Canadian equity balanced fund offerings.
Balanced funds, which invest in stocks and bonds, come in different stripes depending on their equity exposure. (Canadian equity balanced funds must have more than 60 per cent in equities.)
We ranked the top 15 performers for three years ended May 31. U.S. dollar, segregated, pooled and duplicate versions of the funds were excluded. We also left out funds of funds, and those sold to one professional group.
What did we find?Fifteen-per-cent-plus annual returns in three funds. Imaxx Canadian Fixed Pay led the way with a 15.8-per-cent annualized gain, trailed slightly by Lakeview Disciplined Leadership High Income and GBC Growth and Income.
All funds also benefited from the stock-market rebound from the lows of March, 2009. Norrep Income Growth Class posted an even higher 21.7-per-cent return, but a check under the hood indicates it also had another life as an income trust equity fund during the period.
Imaxx Canadian Fixed Pay, which is 80 per cent invested in dividend-paying stocks and the rest in investment-grade corporate bonds, has 40 Canadian equity holdings. The objective is to generate a dividend yield that is 50 per cent greater than the yield of the S&P/TSX composite, which hovers around 2.8 to 2.9 per cent.
"The running yield of the equity portion of the fund is about 4.4 per cent," said portfolio manager Stephen Carlin, also head of equities at Aegon Capital Management Inc. (He also runs fledgling Canoe Equity Income Class, a clone of the Imaxx fund.)
The three-year performance of the Imaxx fund has been propelled by holdings in midstream or infrastructure energy stocks like AltaGas Ltd., Keyera Corp. and Enbridge Inc., as well as, real estate investment trusts like Calloway REIT, Boardwalk REIT and RioCan REIT.
The fund is now 45 per cent invested in financials, including 25 per cent in banks and 20 per cent in REITs. Another 25 per cent is in energy stocks with a bias to the oil sector.
Mr. Carlin is cautious on the Canadian stock market and only expects a mid single-digit return at best this year because of uncertainty arising from Europe's debt crisis and a faltering U.S. economy. "We think we are stuck in a sub-par economic growth environment - something like 2 per cent or less," he said.
TOP 3-YEAR RETURNS FOR CANADIAN EQUITY BALANCED FUNDS TO MAY 31
|Fund name||MER||Assets ($-mil; May 31)||3yr % rtn (May 31)||5yr% rtn (May 31)||2011 % rtn||2010 % rtn||2009 % rtn||2008 % rtn||Minimum Investment $|
|Norrep Income Growth Class-A||4.72||51.0||21.7%||6.3%||2.2%||32.6%||42.3%||-33.6%||5,000|
|imaxx Canadian Fixed Pay||2.67||223.7||15.8%||5.2%||8.4%||17.9%||35.2%||-25.9%||1,000|
|Lakeview Disp Leadership Hi Inc A||2.39||505.6||15.6%||6.7%||6.8%||19.2%||27.0%||-14.3%||500|
|GBC Growth and Income||1.69||32.9||15.2%||3.0%||6.2%||17.2%||20.9%||-25.5%||100,000|
|AGF Monthly High Income||2.40||610.5||14.2%||2.7%||0.3%||19.7%||46.8%||-33.4%||500|
|Bissett Dividend Income-A||2.57||312.6||11.4%||1.4%||5.2%||11.6%||18.7%||-20.0%||500|
|BMO GDN Can Divers Mthly Inc||2.45||316.2||10.8%||1.9%||2.4%||12.7%||25.5%||-22.7%||500|
|Dynamic Diversified Real Asset||2.53||251.6||10.2%||2.7%||-8.0%||28.0%||38.8%||-27.8%||500|
|TD Monthly Income||1.48||5,900.0||10.1%||2.5%||3.6%||9.8%||30.7%||-23.4%||100|
|Trimark Diversified Income Class-T8||2.16||408.8||9.2%||0.8%||2.8%||8.3%||24.5%||-19.4%||500|
|TD Dividend Income-I||2.04||4,719.7||9.2%||-0.1%||1.6%||8.9%||30.8%||-28.8%||100|
|TD Diversified Monthly Income-I||2.31||552.3||8.9%||0.5%||1.6%||10.1%||27.2%||-25.6%||100|
|Brandes Sionna Diversified Income||2.27||71.0||8.6%||-0.8%||-2.1%||12.2%||27.3%||-29.4%||1,000|
|National Bank Monthly Income||1.70||227.3||7.3%||1.1%||-3.7%||13.0%||29.9%||-22.4%||500|
|Renaissance Diversified Income||2.50||85.9||7.0%||-1.6%||-3.6%||11.8%||21.0%||-28.2%||500|
|S&P/TSX Total Return||6.4%||-1.1%||-8.7%||17.6%||35.1%||-33.0%|
|DEX Universe Bond Total Return Index||7.5%||6.9%||9.7%||6.7%||5.4%||6.4%|
© 2007 The Globe and Mail. All rights reserved.
Only GlobeinvestorGOLD combines the strength of powerful investing tools with the insight of The Globe and Mail.
Discover a wealth of investment information and and exclusive features.